Instagram

Translate

Sunday, November 07, 2010

striking journalist

Guardian 6th November:

BBC strike: a dozen journalists, a homemade placard and a former Play School presenter on the picket line

Newsnight's Paul Mason admits: 'It's not the miners' strike'

Maev Kennedy guardian.co.uk, Friday 5 November 2010 16.06 GMT


Paul Mason, Newsnight's economics editor, on the BBC picket line. Photograph: Oli Scarff/Getty Images

By 9am when the BBC's flagship radio news programme, Today, should have been signing off in traditional style by crashing the pips, the ragged line of about a dozen National Union of Journalists pickets was bagging support from passing traffic.

There were flashing headlamps from a No 22 London bus; a tooted horn from a white catering lorry, and one small grey van which, after a chat with the striking journalists, turned back from the gates - to the pickets' surprise.

Meanwhile hundreds of BBC workers had streamed past them into the Wood Lane Television Centre, the heart of the corporation's radio and television news operation, a few looking slightly awkward, most barely registering the pickets. "I'm not in your union, but I support you guys," one man said - but went in anyway.

Helen Boaden, the director of news, smiled and said hello as she walked through, too briskly for the pickets to get out a "BBC pensions robbery" leaflet to offer her. "She's presumably in there now doing all the news programmes by herself," said Ian Pollock, chair of the NUJ London branch at the BBC. "She was very pleasant - but she's still scabbing."

They tried harder to engage with the soon-to-be-redundant deputy director Mark Byford, but he strode through. Peter Horrocks, director of the World Service, paused for long enough to assure them their cause was hopeless.

Paul Mason, Newsnight's economics editor, joined the picket line in battered jeans and pinstripe jacket, insisting: "What we're on strike for is the right to take a pay cut so we can pay more into our own pensions." It was not an issue arousing tremendous public sympathy, he agreed as passersby, clocking that his was the most famous face on offer, hurried on by. "This is not the miners' strike," he said.

The solitary homemade placard, a beautifully lettered "Lose 1/3 of my pension? Of course I'm on strike", on drawing paper nicked from his children, was carried by Ian Jolly, who works for the BBC news website. He spent his very first day as a professional journalist on strike, joining the picket outside the Eastern Daily Press in Norwich in 1978. "This [the BBC strike] has been a very hard sell," he said today. "A lot of people think, 'you're in work, what are you moaning about?' "

A group of pensioners arrived on a coach, a University of the Third Age group from St Albans booked in months ago for a studio tour. "If I was working for the BBC I'd be out on this picket line too," Peter Dodd said staunchly, after a career as an engineer and technical officer in which he was made redundant five times. "The whole state of British employment today is very worrying."

Two slightly bemused Dutch tourists, Lena and Marcel Dam, arrived to join the tour. They got to London on Tuesday, in time for the tube strike. "For us it is very interesting to find Britain like this," Marcel said, guffawing.

Chris Tranchell cheerfully introduced himself as a flying picket, a one-man delegation from Hammersmith and Fulham trades council where he represents the actors' union, Equity. But it turned out he knew the Wood Lane building very well indeed: from 1976 to 1984 he was a regular presenter on Play School. His bosses may already have had his number, since the day he whistled, while narrating a Christmas tree story, the air to O Tannenbaum - or The Red Flag, as it is better known at Labour conferences. He sealed his fate during the miners' strike, when he appeared on the front page of a trade union journal, collecting toys for strikers' children outside Hamley's in Regent Street. He was invited to an ominous lunch with his producer. "The word miner was never mentioned. She told me, 'Chris, your face is no longer coming at us through the camera,' and that was that.

"The cuts are happening everywhere you look. Solidarity among workers is all we've got".

_________________
The salmon-falls, the mackerel-crowded seas
Back to top Go down

Eddie
Head Librarian


Gender: Male Number of posts: 8517
Registration date: 2008-07-30

PostSubject: Re: BBC strike by members of the National Union of Journalists   Yesterday at 6:32 pm

Did the BBC strike spoil your morning?

Nature programmes instead of Radio 4's Today, stand-in presenters on Radio 5 Live ... it was all change on BBC stations



Did you miss John Humphrys' bellowing tones on Radio 4's Today programme? Photograph: BBC

Friday, 6.30am, does not tend to be my favourite point of the week. Oddly it was rather improved this morning by Radio 4's decision to repeat Off the Page: Living Cheap, in lieu of the second half hour of the Today Show. What I couldn't work out was whether broadcasting a programme that came with the blurb "Everyone tells us we are living in tough times. Can we re-learn how to live on the cheap?" smacked of BBC management's evil genius, or fabulous striking journalist mischief. Not only was there a discussion about whether frugality can be fun, but the panel featured a 69-year-old who lives in an almshouse. A warning or a recommendation? That intrigue alone was enough to provide a little fillip to a grey November morning. (If you missed it, you can listen again here. Well worth it .)

Radio 4 was, in fact, the station hardest hit by the 48-hour NUJ strike, with the Today programme completely off air and documentaries about Lord Kitchener and Winston Churchill – disorientating if you turned on halfway through and had to figure out who on earth was being talked about – jostling alongside a couple of instalments of The Estuary. As my colleague Maev Kennedy noted: "Peaceful twittering of wading birds instead of anxious squawking of politicians on R4." The effect was restful, but not particularly useful in terms of delivering news, unless of course you are mad keen on wading birds, although there were 15-minute bulletins on the hour.

Radio 5 Live managed to put out a breakfast show that was closer in format to usual – ie it didn't involve the sounds of birds squawking and some people were interviewed – but actually seemed less of a success because of that. One painful interview about Diwali included the memorable question: "Becoming very popular now isn't it?"

The stand-in presenter, seemed surprisingly reluctant to tell us who he was, so his identity remains something of a mystery to me, although I'm told it was Ian Payne. All I can definitely tell you is that he appeared to have the same voice as the person doing the sport and the travel. The only moments of contrast came when people, often footballers, were interviewed at great length. And then the contrast tended to be a monotone mumble. One interview with Ashley Cole seemed to go on for about half a lifetime.

The same problem hit BBC Breakfast, which was not replaced by repeats, but was reduced to a kind of pared-down BBC News channel with one anchor and a set of packaged stories that sometimes benefited from being given an extra long slot to fill... and sometimes really didn't. One report that seemed essentially to involve a journalist having a go on a Formula One simulator neither particularly informed nor interested me. But then the same could be said of Daybreak in its entirety. And that's on every morning.

Perhaps it was just because I had my eye on different news outlets all at once, but the recycling of guests and stories between BBC Breakfast and Radio 5 Live was also pretty marked in places.

So what did you make of the strike output? Were you lost without the Today programme? I honestly still have no idea what is actually happening in the world because it hasn't been hammered into my mind by a shouty John Humphrys. Were you too bemused by the many promos on BBC Breakfast for BBC news services you presumably can't access at the moment? And did you feel a bit sorry for Victoria Derbyshire who is presumably on strike, but has had her show covered by repeats of her earlier interviews, which rather dilutes the effect?

Your thoughts please – particularly if you have local updates.
Posted by Vicky Frost Friday 5 November 2010 12.16 GMT guardian.co.uk



No comments:

Post a Comment