read more, click here
Here is a statement from a senior Iranian cleric saying women who wear revealing clothing and behave promiscuously are to blame for earthquakes (it proves wrong by the research title "Boobquake")What turned into a viral media extravaganza began as a humorous science experiment. On Monday 19 April, I had just read Iranian cleric Hojatoleslam Kazem Sedighi's assertion that "Many women who do not dress modestly ... lead young men astray, corrupt their chastity and spread adultery in society, which (consequently) increases earthquakes." Amused and annoyed by his ludicrous statement, I suggested on my blog that women dress immodestly on 26 April to test his claims. Tongue-in-cheek, I dubbed the project "Boobquake".
When I first published that fateful blogpost, I thought it would only be enjoyed by my friends and thousand readers. It ended in almost a million unique visits to my blog, thousands of emails, and coverage by CNN, the BBC, and (more importantly to a liberal nerdy college student) the Colbert Report. People around the world engaged in intense debate about how it affected women's rights, Muslims, and Iranians.
To be honest, global discussion and awareness were not my original goal – that wasn't even feasible in my mind. Though I'm glad it happened, I also want to stress the original message behind Boobquake. As a scientist and a sceptic, I firmly believe that we should test claims people make, especially when they're ridiculous. And as an atheist, I don't think supernatural beliefs are exempt from this questioning.
Because Sedighi's hypothesis was testable, how could we not investigate further? Wouldn't it have been fascinating if we did find out tight pants and cleavage controlled natural disasters? That would surely be worthy of Nature or Science, a great thing for a young scientist like myself to have on her resume. I quickly went to work. After recruiting over a 100,000 women somewhat accidentally thanks to Facebook and Twitter, we dressed in our most immodest outfits on the 26 April. And on the 27th, I crunched the numbers.
But just to be safe, I also looked at the overall distribution of the magnitudes of earthquakes on Boobquake (figure two). These samples span from the entirety of the event – midnight at the earliest time zone to midnight at the last time. The box indicates the first and third quartiles (within which 50% of the data points fall). Not only did all of the earthquakes on Boobquake fall within the normal range of magnitudes, but the mean magnitude actually decreased slightly! Maybe God actually approves of hot pants.
Obviously this study had its flaws. To really be scientifically rigorous, we'd have to increase our sample size by repeating Boobquake on other days. We didn't have a control planet of women covered head to toe, and we didn't have a good way to quantify how much we increased immodesty (what's the unit of immodesty anyway? Intensity of red on blushing nuns?) Maybe we didn't lead men astray enough, or maybe God is just biding his time before crumbling my apartment in a freak Indiana earthquake.
Even though Boobquake wasn't perfect, it still was a success. Some people created counter-protests like Brainquake," thinking that my idea lacked real substance because of indecent male detractors. But the vast majority of people – including earthquake researchers, feminists, and many Iranians – thanked me for this exercise in scepticism. The boob joke probably made it popular, but hopefully the smarts will make it memorable.
"Many women who do not dress modestly ... lead young men astray, corrupt their chastity and spread adultery in society, which (consequently) increases earthquakes," Hojatoleslam Kazem Sedighi was quoted as saying by Iranian media. (AP)
No comments:
Post a Comment