Instagram

Translate

Saturday, October 03, 2009

hiding from the truth

Stop blaming the poor. It's the wally yachters who are burning the planet | George Monbiot | Comment is free | The Guardian

It's time we had the guts to name the problem. It's not sex; it's money. It's not the poor; it's the rich.
t's no coincidence that most of those who are obsessed with population growth are post-reproductive wealthy white men: it's about the only environmental issue for which they can't be blamed. The brilliant Earth systems scientist James Lovelock, for instance, claimed last month that "those who fail to see that population growth and climate change are two sides of the same coin are either ignorant or hiding from the truth. These two huge environmental problems are inseparable and to discuss one while ignoring the other is irrational." But it's Lovelock who is being ignorant and irrational.

A paper published yesterday in the journal Environment and Urbanization shows that the places where population has been growing fastest are those in which carbon dioxide has been growing most slowly, and vice versa. Between 1980 and 2005, for instance, sub-Saharan Africa produced 18.5% of the world's population growth and just 2.4% of the growth in CO2. North America turned out only 4% of the extra people, but 14% of the extra emissions. Sixty-three percent of the world's population growth happened in places with very low emissions.

Even this does not capture it. The paper points out that about one sixth of the world's population is so poor that it produces no significant emissions at all. This is also the group whose growth rate is likely to be highest. Households in India earning less than 3,000 rupees (£40) a month use a fifth of the electricity per head and one seventh of the transport fuel of households earning 30,000 rupees or more. Street sleepers use almost nothing. Those who live by processing waste (a large part of the urban underclass) often save more greenhouse gases than they produce.

Many of the emissions for which poorer countries are blamed should in fairness belong to the developed nations. Gas flaring by companies exporting oil from Nigeria, for instance, has produced more greenhouse gases than all other sources in sub-Saharan Africa put together. Even deforestation in poor countries is driven mostly by commercial operations delivering timber, meat and animal feed to rich consumers. The rural poor do far less harm.



2 comments:

  1. Nice article. Therese days I rarely see people who understand that the real problem is money. So, happy to see this.

    I have also written an article on my blog on the same lines... You might want to check it out and evaluate. Do if you like.

    How poverty can(not) be removed?

    http://www.darshanchande.com/2009/05/how-poverty-cannot-be-removed.html

    ReplyDelete
  2. Absolutely correct!! Nowadays, even the poor is after money... What can you say.. Is there a way we don't use money?

    ReplyDelete